A Failed or Worn-out Knee Replacement
When a previous knee replacement becomes painful, unstable, or no longer functions as expected
Knee replacement surgery, often called knee arthroplasty, is a procedure designed to relieve pain, restore function, and enhance the quality of life for those affected by knee arthritis or other knee-related conditions. This surgery involves replacing the damaged or worn-out surfaces of the knee joint with artificial implants made of metal and plastic.
Like any surgical procedure however, knee replacement surgery carries certain risks and the possibility of complications during or after the procedure. In some instances, the knee replacement may not achieve the desired outcome or may lead to further issues, necessitating a revision procedure. A revision surgery involves re-operating to replace or adjust part or all of the original implants.
While many complications that arise with knee replacement surgery can be managed effectively and don’t necessarily lead to joint replacement failure, knee replacement failure generally refers to issues that cannot be resolved without revision surgery. This might involve ongoing pain, instability, or restricted function, indicating the artificial joint is no longer performing as intended.
SYMPTOMS OF A COMPLICATED OR FAILED KNEE REPLACEMENT
If you notice any of the following symptoms, it is important to consult your orthopaedic surgeon for further evaluation and advice:
It is normal to experience some pain as part of recovery in the initial weeks to months after surgery. However, persistent, severe pain beyond the expected healing period may indicate issues such as implant loosening, infection, or instability. Patients may notice different types of pain, including a deep ache, sharp pain during movement, or pain that worsens with weight-bearing activities. Each may signal specific issues and should be assessed by a healthcare professional if it persists.
Instability in a knee replacement can feel like the knee is “giving out” or not fully supporting weight, particularly during activities like walking or climbing stairs. This may result from ligament imbalance, loosening of the implants, or poor alignment of the knee joint. An unstable knee replacement should be evaluated to prevent falls and further joint damage.
A successful knee replacement generally restores a range of motion suitable for daily activities. Difficulty in bending or straightening the knee can indicate complications such as scar tissue formation (arthrofibrosis), malalignment of the implant, or loosening of components. Prolonged stiffness that doesn’t improve with physiotherapy or exercise may require additional treatment to improve movement and comfort.
Some swelling is common shortly after surgery, but it usually subsides as the knee heals. Swelling that persists or worsens over time could be due to inflammation, infection, or an underlying issue with the implant. Swelling accompanied by warmth, redness, or tenderness may point to infection, which requires prompt medical attention to prevent further complications.
Mild warmth around the knee is common in early recovery however, persistent warmth, especially alongside redness, may suggest infection or inflammation. Bruising is typical after surgery, but ongoing skin discolouration or darkening around the knee can indicate problems, particularly if accompanied by pain and swelling.
While some minor clicking may occur as the knee moves, frequent or worsening sounds, such as grinding, may indicate joint misalignment or wear on the implant. If the knee feels rough or gritty during movement, this could suggest issues with the implant surfaces or loosening, which may impact function and comfort.
Infection is a serious but rare complication that can occur around a knee replacement. Signs include fever, chills, increasing pain, swelling, redness, or discharge from the incision. Infections can be challenging to treat and may require antibiotics or even revision surgery if the infection spreads to the implant.
Knee joint issues can sometimes place strain on other parts of the leg, causing pain in areas like the hip, thigh, or ankle. This may signal joint alignment issues or implant loosening. Sometimes, pain originating in the knee can be felt elsewhere. Monitoring any new or worsening pain in surrounding joints is important to assess overall joint function.
A knee replacement aims to improve mobility and quality of life. If patients notice a decline in their ability to walk, climb stairs, or perform everyday activities due to knee discomfort, this could indicate that the implant is not functioning as intended. If mobility deteriorates after initial improvement, a medical assessment can help determine the underlying cause and appropriate next steps.
Patients might notice visible changes in the knee’s alignment or shape, such as a bow-legged or knock-kneed appearance, which could signal implant loosening or instability. Bulging or indentation around the knee may also suggest implant issues or tissue swelling and should be reviewed by an orthopaedic specialist.
COMMON COMPLICATIONS WITH KNEE REPLACEMENT SURGERY
Complications after knee replacement surgery can vary in type, timing, and severity. Recognising these issues early and understanding potential causes can help manage them effectively and support a smoother recovery.
- INFECTION: Infection is a risk associated with any surgery and can affect the skin, soft tissues, bone, or implants. It may present as pain, swelling, redness, fever, drainage, or loosening of the implants. Infections are caused by bacteria, viruses, fungi, or other microorganisms entering the surgical site, bloodstream, or implants. Following strict hygiene and wound care, along with antibiotic protocols before, during, and after surgery, can help prevent infection. If infection occurs, it may be treated with antibiotics, drainage, or debridement, and severe cases may require revision surgery.
- BLOOD CLOTS: Blood clots may form post-surgery and can be dangerous if they travel to the lungs or heart. Medications and preventive measures, such as compression devices and early mobilisation, are used to manage this risk.
- IMPLANT LOOSENING: Loosening can occur over time as the implants wear out or detach from the bone, leading to pain, instability, and reduced mobility. Factors such as implant design, material, size, alignment, bone quality, infection, inflammation, and high-impact activities can contribute to loosening. Choosing the appropriate implant, ensuring precise placement, maintaining bone health, and following recommended activity levels can help reduce loosening risks. If loosening occurs, revision surgery may be needed to replace implants, add bone grafts or metal supports, or adjust fixation methods.
- STIFFNESS: Some patients may experience stiffness in the knee following surgery, which can affect movement and comfort. Physiotherapy and a structured rehabilitation program can often help reduce stiffness, improve range of motion, and support recovery.
- KNEE INSTABILITY: Knee instability may result from issues with implant positioning or surrounding ligaments, leading to a sensation of the knee “giving way.” Bracing or, in some cases, revision surgery may be recommended to improve stability.
Most complications following knee replacement surgery can be effectively managed with physiotherapy, medication, and regular follow-ups. Identifying these issues early allows patients to seek timely intervention, enhancing comfort and overall outcomes. Dr Liddell works closely with each patient to monitor recovery and provides tailored support and guidance to address any concerns during the healing process.
WHAT CAN CAUSE A KNEE REPLACEMENT TO FAIL?
Several factors can contribute to knee replacement failure over time, affecting the success and durability of the implant.
- Implant Loosening: Loosening of the implant from the bone may occur due to excessive joint stress, infection, or natural wear and tear. Patients with high activity levels may be at greater risk.
- Infection: An infection in the joint space can damage surrounding tissues and compromise the implant. This may occur during surgery or through bacteria entering the bloodstream from other infections.
- Wear and Tear of Implants: Regular activity, especially high-impact movement, may cause the materials to wear down over time. Particles from this wear can irritate nearby tissues, causing inflammation.
- Alignment Issues: Proper alignment of the implant is essential for joint function. Misalignment, whether from surgery or changes in the surrounding soft tissue, can place uneven stress on the joint.
- Scar Tissue Build-Up (Arthrofibrosis): Excessive scar tissue can cause stiffness and reduced movement, making it difficult to achieve a full range of motion. This complication is managed with physiotherapy or, if necessary, surgical intervention.
WAYS TO REDUCE THE RISK OF KNEE REPLACEMENT COMPLICATIONS
Knee replacement surgery is a well-established procedure that may help relieve pain and improve function for individuals with severe knee arthritis or damage. While modern surgical techniques and implants have contributed to successful outcomes, all surgeries carry some risks. Taking proactive steps before and after your knee replacement may help reduce the likelihood of complications and support a smoother recovery.
Optimising Your Health
Your overall health plays a key role in your surgical outcome. Before your knee replacement, your surgeon may recommend:
- Maintaining a healthy weight – Excess body weight increases stress on the knee joint and can impact recovery.
- Managing underlying conditions – Conditions such as diabetes, heart disease, or high blood pressure should be well controlled to reduce surgical risks.
- Stopping smoking – Smoking affects blood circulation and can delay healing. Quitting before surgery may help reduce complications.
- Improving nutrition – A balanced diet rich in protein, vitamins, and minerals may aid healing and reduce infection risks.
Strengthening Your Muscles
A prehabilitation (prehab) program guided by a physiotherapist may improve muscle strength, flexibility, and joint function before surgery. Stronger muscles around the knee can provide better support during recovery.
Screening for Infections
Any existing infections, including dental infections, urinary tract infections, or skin infections, should be treated before surgery to lower the risk of post-operative infections.
Selecting the Right Implant and Surgical Approach
Dr Liddell will discuss the most appropriate implant and surgical technique based on your knee anatomy, lifestyle, and health factors. Advancements in knee replacement technology, including patient-specific instrumentation (PSI) and navigation-assisted surgery, may help enhance precision and improve outcomes.
Minimising Blood Clot Risk
To reduce the risk of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) after surgery, your care team may recommend:
- Blood-thinning medications, if appropriate
- Wearing compression stockings
- Using intermittent pneumatic compression devices
- Early mobilisation and leg exercises
Following Your Rehabilitation Plan
Adhering to your post-operative physiotherapy plan is essential for regaining knee strength and mobility. Regular exercises and guided rehabilitation may help prevent stiffness and improve function.
Preventing Infection
To lower the risk of infection after surgery:
- Keep the surgical site clean and dry
- Follow wound care instructions
- Watch for signs of infection, such as increased redness, swelling, or drainage, and seek prompt medical attention if needed
Managing Pain and Swelling
Pain management strategies, including prescribed medications, ice therapy, and elevation, may help keep discomfort under control and support early movement.
Avoiding Falls and Injuries
Taking precautions to prevent falls in the early recovery period is important. Consider:
- Using assistive devices, such as crutches or a walker, as recommended
- Removing trip hazards at home
- Installing handrails or grab bars in key areas, such as bathrooms
Attending Follow-Up Appointments
Regular check-ups with Dr Liddell allow for ongoing assessment of your knee replacement and early detection of any concerns.
Maintaining a Healthy Lifestyle
Long-term knee health can be supported by:
- Staying active with low-impact exercises, such as swimming or cycling
- Avoiding excessive impact activities that may place stress on the implant
- Maintaining a healthy weight to reduce joint strain
By following these proactive measures, you may help reduce the risk of complications and optimise the long-term success of your knee replacement. During your consultation, Dr Liddell will provide personalised advice based on your health and recovery goals.